Back to Blog

How to Scrape Research Papers, Patents, and Clinical Trials Legally?

---

As the world transitions into a data-driven era, access to structured scientific knowledge (i.e., research articles, patents, clinical trials) is more important than ever. Researchers, developers, and data scientists are utilizing these datasets to provide new technologies, gain exploratory insights, and advance overall knowledge. However, without a thorough understanding of the information to be scraped, there could be serious legal and ethical ramifications. Knowing what data can be scraped and how to do that responsibly is imperative.

The guide examines the legalities of data scraping, outlines best ethical practices, and discusses various available tools and strategies for safely accessing value-added scientific content. This could be for academic research, for training a model for amplitude in AI, or for developing new products. The first step to creating trustworthy, forward-thinking solutions is to learn how to collect the data ethically and legally.

Understanding What Can Be Scraped

To commence the scraping process legally, an understanding of what is publicly accessible and the conditions under which it can be accessed will be essential. Research papers are sometimes publicly accessible, with many being open-access on platforms like arXiv, PubMed Central, Semantic Scholar, and CORE. Most are publicly accessible with metadata and sometimes full text, often under Creative Commons licensing. Patents, which are public information, are freely available on sites such as USPTO, WIPO, and Google Patents.

Patents provide a wealth of structured data, including abstracts, claims, and a unique patent classification. Clinical trial data are also available as public information, particularly from government sources, as well as through publicly accessible databases such as ClinicalTrials.gov, the EU Clinical Trials Register (EU-CTR), and the WHO ICTRP. These databases provide, at a minimum, trial ID, outcomes (primary, secondary, etc., sometimes reported), locations (country-level), and sponsors/funders. Before performing any scraping or data collection, verify the access and terms of use for the data. You would typically have legal access to public content not just by the type of content that is publicly available but also by the terms of service of the publisher and whether the data is provided in an outward-facing way (e.g., an article is publicly available, but you are accessing/scraping the site in an automated way).

Legal Considerations

It is necessary to respect the law when scraping off any research data. The first step is to check the terms of service and robots.txt file of the website from which you are scraping. The terms of service and robots.txt usually tell you what you can and cannot do with automated access. For research-related papers, copyright is an important consideration: many of the oldest extant open access articles we can reuse because of the licensing most journals nowadays are protected by copyright. Generally, patents are public domain but still must be accessed through the official policies and patterns of access.

What Are Ethical Web Scraping Practices?

While legal compliance is essential, ethical responsibility is important on a whole new level in terms of acknowledging responsible access to data. Ethical scraping involves respecting data ownership, usage rights, and the inherent responsibilities cultivated by the ecosystem you are accessing for your goals. Always use rate limiting and try to avoid scraping during peak times for servers, and only scrape what you need. Identify your use case by using user-agent headers and provide contact information. This expression of transparency is goodwill from your scraped resources.

When you use scraped data in the public domain, provide attributions and citations, and give specific mention to metadata that was developed from articles or research databases. Never scrape something that is forbidden or privately accessible, even if it is publicly accessible.

If you are scraping data from clinical trials, then you have to be even more vigilant in order to avoid compromising privacy, as with health data it is especially sensitive. Most importantly, following ethical practices places you in a good position to not only limit your risk of retribution but also build trust with the data source so that they may want to allow you to continue a more open access policy and a long-term sharing of this source of data with the research community.

How to Scrape Research Papers, Patents, and Clinical Trials Legally?

• 1. Find Your Source: Look for reputable, legal sources like PubMed, ClinicalTrials.gov, or arXiv.
• 2. Choose Your Tool:
  • Use made-for-you tools like ParseHub or Octoparse for simple tasks.
  • Use Python libraries (for more sophisticated uses) such as Requests or BeautifulSoup for more control.
• 3. Consider the Legality:
  • Check for a robots.txt file and see if the site has terms of service or any other information related to crawling.
  • Verify if it is permissible to use (e.g., Creative Commons, public domain).
• 4. Use the API If Available:
  • PubMed, arXiv, and ClinicalTrials.gov all have structured methods for gaining access.
• 5. Stick to Best Practices:
  • Include user-agent headers, set rate limits, and log all activity.
  • Export data in usable formats (e.g., CSV, JSON), and consider pagination.

Following this checklist can lead to high-quality, ethical, and legal data.

What Are The Best Practices Based On Data Type?

Different types of data require different approaches to access them legally and securely. When writing research papers, ensure that you use open-access websites, which permit the unrestricted use of ideas and information. Do not try to scrape paid or subscription content because you do not have an explicit right to do so. Another way to obtain research information is to utilize APIs, which allow you to access the information legally.

For patents, you can use the official websites like the USPTO and WIPO. They both provide access to patented information that is sufficient for you to use and easy to read (for example, XML and JSON formats). You can even use Google's BigQuery tool to search and start working with large patent datasets.

For clinical trials, use only trusted sources, such as ClinicalTrials.gov or the WHO ICTRP. These sites provide bulk download options and APIs. Be very careful about collecting private or personal health information; don't try to identify individuals from the data.

Using the correct method of data access when working with different types of data helps you maintain legal and ethical standards and integrity in your work.

What Are Legal Alternatives to Scraping?

Scraping may seem like the right path forward, yet if you consider other possibilities, there are many legitimate and reasonable options. Bulk download sites, such as ClinicalTrials.gov, include a bulk XML or JSON dataset available to the public. Datasets provided in XML or JSON format will typically be documented, consistent, updated regularly, well-structured, and ready for straightforward incorporation into analysis. Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) may also be a viable option.

In some institutional contexts, researchers may have a legal right to download or mine data from a subscription service, given their institution subscribes to the service. Often, these services will have the option to export data so that users will not need to scrape markup text.

In addition, data-sharing consortia or collaborative research networks are other options to consider. The organization providing the access will often be able to denote a high-quality, legally acquired dataset for researchers' or other public uses. Utilizing alternate options will often mean researchers will have less accountability verifying the originality of the data, greater scalability, and reduced legal risks and can think in terms of the ethical access afforded to them by the data-sharing organization.

Why Use APIs for Legal and Efficient Data Access?

When you're responsibly collecting research data, APIs are one of the safest and most effective methods to collect data. APIs are not like scraping webpages; APIs are made for access to databases in a structured and reliable way. You don’t violate the terms of service, while scraping often does. Most commonly known platforms encourage and support developers and researchers to use their APIs, so they are the preferred method for legal data extraction.

Why APIs rather than scraping?

• Legal Compliance: APIs are offered with terms of use rights, so there is less legal risk on your end.
• Structured data: APIs provide clean data and usually machine-readable answers in JSON or XML or similar.
• Manage rate-limiting: platforms usually provide explicit limiting to avoid being blocked.
• Sustainable data access: API access is less volatile than parsing HTML, which can change with a flip of a switch.

What Are The Common Mistakes to Avoid?

Numerous data collectors make mistakes that could easily be avoided. Data collectors make mistakes that can potentially lead them to technical trouble or legal trouble. One common mistake is 'ignoring' terms of service requirements or robots.txt rules that describe the acceptable access behavior for a website. Violating these Terms of Service requirements or robots.txt rules can lead to IP bans or even legal complaints. Another error is making too many requests in an unanticipated burst that overwhelms web services and triggers anti-bot protections.

Rate limiting and controlling your backoff strategy should always be implemented. Many mistakenly scrape or disseminate copyrighted content without specifically verifying licenses from academic journals. When collecting content, verify that the content is under an open license or use the metadata of the reference. Using or scraping content for commercial purposes but without knowing or understanding the licensing terms is also a risk.

Many datasets and APIs were cataloged only for non-commercial purposes unless otherwise licensed and not listed as otherwise restricted. Finally, poor data housekeeping, such as not validating fields or considering whether or not they broke attribution, could often jeopardize the integrity of research. Practicing good data collection allows users to protect themselves from errors or mistakes while keeping with good practices and ethics as a member of the research and data science community.

The Future of Data Access: Trends and Technologies

Access to research data is changing rapidly. With open data initiatives like Plan S and publicly funded research findings/philosophies in the public domain, there's an expectation that public research with taxpayer support should be accessible to the public so users can legally access, explore, and reuse the data. Additionally, decentralized science (DeSci) is using blockchain-based models of publication and dissemination, leveraging a decentralized system, to move away from traditional publishers and then producing an open and transparent process. There is a huge need for AI-ready datasets, and there are already some datasets that have structured data intended for machine learning. In addition, semantic search technologies on platforms offer a much more intuitive way to discover data and avoid legacy scraping procedures.

Conclusion

Learning to scrape research data involves more than just understanding how to operate the tool; it also requires a deeper understanding of the data itself. It also involves an innovative, legal, and ethical approach. As we have covered in this playbook, it is vital to read and act on any stipulations in the website policy, to choose open-access sources, to utilize the 'front door' with APIs or bulk downloads, and to act ethically while scraping.

If you can avoid the traps and pitfalls of scraping and choose the appropriate approach to scraping regardless of the unique type of data you wish to utilize, you should be able to scrape any data without walls getting in the way. New trends, such as decentralized science and AI-ready datasets, are also creating new ways in which data can be shared and utilized.

At Scraping Intelligence, we back being responsible data collectors; we intend to ensure we do so "responsibly," with care, legally, and respectfully every step of the way. Through that commitment, not only are you collecting data, but you are also fostering trust in a shared and collaborative future for research. Reach out to Scraping Intelligence if you are looking to extract valuable data and are a responsible participant in the global research community.

---